QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE

Order! Members on my right. We are going to have order today, and we are going to do question time in a dignified manner.

I appreciate the member was asking the question, but when I explained to him the question about why you now have bulk-billing rates that are in crisis, of course the minister is going to give his view on why he doesn't think that or believes that is the case. I gave you a fair go. You are going to leave the chamber under 94(a).

The member for Longman then left the chamber.