QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE

Senator WHITEAKER (Western Australia) (14:14): The Prime Minister, Treasurer and Minister for Finance have all been clear that tonight's budget will be responsible and sustainable and that the budget bottom line will be stronger because of the government's decisions. Can the minister outline how responsible budgeting— Opposition senators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Senator Whiteaker, I'm very sorry.

Senator Whiteaker has the right to ask her question in silence. Senator McKenzie: The comedy festival's next month! The PRESIDENT: After requesting silence, Senator McKenzie, you always have to have the last word.

I invite you to listen in silence or leave the chamber. Senator WHITEAKER: Can the minister outline how responsible budgeting is helping fund the services Australians rely on while strengthening the budget?